HITs for HAL

Amazon.com has out-googled Google with its creepily brilliant Mechanical Turk service, a means of embedding human beings in software code. If you’re writing a program that requires a task that people can do better than computers (identifying buildings in a photograph, say), you can write a few lines of code to tap into the required human intelligence through Mechanical Turk. The request automatically gets posted on the Turk site, and people carry out the Human Intelligence Task, or HIT, for a fee set by the programmer, with Amazon taking a commission.

As Amazon explains, this turns the usual computer-human interface on its, uh, head:

When we think of interfaces between human beings and computers, we usually assume that the human being is the one requesting that a task be completed, and the computer is completing the task and providing the results. What if this process were reversed and a computer program could ask a human being to perform a task and return the results? What if it could coordinate many human beings to perform a task?

I have no clue how useful Mechanical Turk will prove immediately, but Philipp Lenssen (who foresaw the service in a remarkable post earlier this year) thinks the “potential is immense.” Certainly, the implications are mind-bending. In an essay I discussed last week, George Dyson described how the Internet provides a platform, or operating system, that enables computers to harness and learn from the work of people: “Operating systems make it easier for human beings to operate computers. They also make it easier for computers to operate human beings.” Google uses this capacity implicitly by basing its search engine on human actions and decisions – as we make our daily strolls through the Web, Google gets smarter. Amazon’s Mechanical Turk uses the capacity explicitly, turning people into a “human layer” in software.

But let’s not get too comfortable in our new role. No one, after all, is indispensable.

4 thoughts on “HITs for HAL

  1. Sean Convery

    Coding Humans Into Your Security Apps

    Nicholas Carr’s blog alerted me to a fascinating new service from Amazon called Mechanical Turk. It is named after the mechanical chess-playing automaton with a human hid inside from the late 1700s. The basic idea is through a web-services API y…

  2. Blunderford

    Mechanical Turk Can Make You Rich!!!!!!!!!

    For people unable to move because they weigh 700 pounds, this might be a good program. They can earn some money while not having to move (which they can’t), so it’s better than a job that requires them to move (which they can’t). Otherwise, the progr…

  3. Computerworld Blogs

    MS Singularity causes a sensation (and open source puzzle)

    In today’s IT Blogwatch, we look at Microsoft’s Singularity OS research project. Not to mention an open source LED puzzle-blocks game, which "brings the flexibility inherent in digital software to a physical tile that people can touch and interact wi

Comments are closed.